On Mondays, I share books read for children and teens and link up with Jen at TeachMentorTexts and Kellee and Ricki at UnleashingReaders. Others link to share adult books with Sheila at Book Journeys who started the meme a long time ago.
Come visit, and tweet at #IMWAYR. Thanks to Jen, Kellee, and Ricki for hosting!
Behind The Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death, and Hope In A Mumbai Undercity
- written by Katherine Boo
This book won the National Book Award for 2012, among others, and meets
the criteria for the award challenge at Gathering
Books. Click on the badge on the
right for more information.
I
really wish I could just give link after link of the glowing reviews of this
book, long on my list of books to read, and I finally did take time to read
slowly, savor the beauty that Katherine Boo shared of these people in
circumstances hard to imagine. And I find it hard to see how they did/do
survive. While there may be better circumstances here in the U.S., there are
equally terrible places for children who are trapped in them with few ways to
change. Boo follows several families, especially the children of those
families, the way they start work early, at seven sometimes, the way they learn
to scavenge and steal, then sell the goods for what seems like nothing, but to
them, IS something. They live and survive in cobbled-together shacks in a slum
named Annawadi, in sight, but fenced off, from the wealthy and beautiful Mumbai
airport and its hotels. It is humbling to read this, trying not to judge my own
life and others, wondering if I do enough to help. There is such need here and
in other countries. Here are some words
that made me pause, among many others: “In America and in Europe, it was said,
people know what is going to happen when they turn on the water tap or flick
the light switch. In India, a land of few safe assumptions, chronic uncertainty
was said to have helped produce a nation of quick-witted, creative problem-solvers.”
Among the poor, there was no doubt that instability fostered ingenuity,
but over time the lack of a link between effort and result could become
debilitating. “We try so many things,” as one Annawadi girl put it, ‘but the
world doesn’t move in our favor.’”
Two books discovered at a fabulous Sanibel Island
bookshop (there happen to be three) named MacIntosh Books and Paper. Both are
by local authors and signed! If I didn’t have to pack all the books home in my
suitcase, I would have purchased more! These two are for the granddaughters.
For Imogene, readying again for school, last year
before kindergarten, and who loves monsters.
Go To School, Little Monster - written by
Helen Ketteman and illustrated by Bonnie Leick
Who
wouldn’t be a bit intimidated when you arrive at school, and find out that the
teacher is named “Mr. Drool”. And now I’ve imitated the way this story goes, in
rhyme, with all the silliest monsters Bonnie Leick can dream up, adding funny
details like worms coming out of the apple on the teacher’s desk, and strange
icky things sticking out of sandwiches at lunch. But there are dragons and
ogres to ride on the playground, and a new classmate who is a bit scary at the
beginning, but by the end, becomes a new best friend, and all have a great
first day. The story is funny, just right for younger kids who love the monster
ideas, and it brings up a few anxious times on the first day of school, like
getting to know that “monster” who is sitting beside you.
For Ingrid, one more manatee book, the animal she
studied all year in her school, and saw here for the first time. What a joy it
was to see her see this mama and two babies. Here's one of the pictures.
I Am A Manatee, Yes, I Am - written by
Rosalie Tagg Masella and illustrated by Kimberlee C. Alemian
Here lie the basic facts, and perhaps a
few new ones not known, like manatees have “marching molars”, growing new ones
when the old ones wear out. I’ve never heard this term and wonder if Ingrid
has. The book is filled with gorgeous watercolor illustrations that match the
facts page by page.
Two found and enjoyed at the Captiva Library
Emmanuel’s Dream - written by Laurie Ann
Thompson
and illustrated by Sean Qualls
Finally I found this book and got to enjoy it as so many others have
shared its joy. An inspiration throughout, starting with Emmanuel’s mother, who
wouldn’t give up her son just because he was born without the use of one leg.
She insisted that he figure out how to do things to help, like carry water, and
he did. No one would play with him, so he saved his money and bought a soccer
ball, said he was to be allowed to play if anyone else wanted to use the ball.
He played! Emmanuel may have been born using only one leg, yet showed more
persistence and endurance than others with two. He became disgusted with the
way the disabled were treated in his country, Ghana, so set out on a cross
country ride to show how much is possible. He wore a t-short with the words The
Pozo, meaning “disabled person”. He now continues to fight for the rights of
the disabled all over the world. This story is a must for everyone to read, not
just teachers to children, but for all to learn that having a disability is
just one part of what someone is, not all the parts.
Saltypie, A Choctaw Journey From Darkness
Into Light - written by Tim Tingle and illustrated by Karen Clarkson
What a wonderful book I found. Tim tells the story of his grandmother, who
taught him that whenever a bad thing happened, she called it Saltypie. She
moved with her family to a little house in Oklahoma, stepped out on the porch
the first morning to enjoy the beauty, and was hit on the head by a rock. Part
of the story relays the family closeness brought by his grandmother’s attitude.
Saltypie is what sometimes happens, but then how you deal with it is the
important part. Tim Tingle’s great, great-grandfather was part of the group of
Choctaw Native Americans who walked the Trail of Tears. His biography on the
flyleaf shows him to be an important storyteller, and this is a story I enjoyed
very much. There is a part of the story toward the end that shows the
grandmother having an eye transplant, surprising him because he had never known
she couldn’t see. It’s a story told with love, and beautifully shown in the
portraits drawn by Karen Clarkson.
There
is an important piece by Tingle at the back concerning the question, “How much
should we tell them?” This means that sometimes when people tell too much of
the injustices they face every day, others don’t believe them, so they tell only
a part of it. He speaks of the stereotypes faced, that they never used buffalo
skins, nor lived in teepees, but lived in houses, had gardens and farms, just
like the white people. It is an important piece, reminds me of the words used
by the Wampanoag Native Americans who are in
the Plymouth area: “We are still here.” They share how people are surprised
that there are still Native Americans living today.
Next: I'm reading The Scorpio Rules by Erin Bow, from NetGalley. So far it's intriguing, and I suspect will be exciting. I'm just starting to discover characters, the way this future society works, etc.
I love discovering new book stores on vacation. It looks like you found some treasures at both of them to take home. I read a novel by Tim Tingle last year and loved it. I want to read the Saltypie one now--what a powerful concept.
ReplyDeleteI will look for more by Tim Tingle, too, Kay. This book was a wonderful one to discover. And yes, I did have fun at the bookstores-always lovely to browse in a new store. Thanks!
DeleteThose books stores sound like they were filled with treasures. I'll have to check for The Scorpion Rules because I like Erin Bow's writing. Come see my week here. Happy reading!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Kathy, Erin Bow is new to me so I will need to look for more by her, too! The bookstores were great, each one had its own flavor!
DeleteHi there Linda, I am truly intrigued by Emmanuel's Dream - I hope that we have this one now in our library. I've been meaning to get to Behind the Beautiful Forevers - so glad that you linked it up with the AWB Reading Challenge. Well, hopefully, I get to read this book before the year ends. Sounds like a very important novel. :)
ReplyDeleteHope you will find Emmanuel's Dream. I enjoyed it so much, Myra. And, well, you see what I think of Behind The Beautiful Forevers-sorry I'm put it off so long. Thank you!
DeleteYeah, Emmanuel's Dream!
ReplyDeleteThe Monster book sounds cute! I think there are a bunch of monster books coming out this year.
I loved the detail of the illustration in this monster book, Michele. It was great to look for all of the funny ones. And yes, loved Emmanuel's Dream-finally found it!
DeleteI am excited to read Saltypie. This is a new one to me. I will also pass it on to a few teachers who could use this this year. thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteSaltypie is worth sharing for sure, Joanne, a lovely and important story.
DeleteThe manatee book looks interesting. I love finding books during vacation too and especially when they're something I normally wouldn't see elsewhere.
ReplyDeleteIngrid has read many manatee books this year, but there was this one & more at the library. Yes, finding 'local' books is fun, agreed, Earl.
DeleteI love Tim Tingle and Saltypie is on my list of books to read. Reading your review of Behind The Beautiful Forevers made my heart ache. I don't know if we can ever do enough, but just one thing is better than doing nothing. I've requested this from our local library.
ReplyDeleteI like hearing what you thought of Behind The Beautiful Forevers, Cheriee. It is a powerfully poignant story. I will look for more Tim Tingle books too!
DeleteI listened to the audio of Behind the Beautiful Forevers. So powerful!
ReplyDeleteAs you read my review, I agree, Holly.
DeleteI absolutely loved Emmanuel and am glad you did, too! After your review of Behind The Beautiful Forevers, I need to get it!
ReplyDeleteI've known it was an important book for a long while, but kept putting it aside, now glad I read it, but it wasn't easy, Ricki. Emmanuel's Dream is inspiring.
DeleteGo to School Little Monsters looks adorable. I need to seek that one out.
ReplyDeleteIt is darling, Beth. If you like these cute monster books, it's for you!
DeleteEmmanuel's Dream is such an important book. I'm glad you liked it :)
ReplyDeleteLittle Monster looks so fun! Thank you for sharing!
Happy reading this week! :)
Thanks, Kellee. Hope you'll find and laugh with Little Monster! And best wishes for a good week!
DeleteLots of new-to-me titles here Linda. Saltypie and Behind the Beautiful Forevers. I loved Emmanuel's Dream! Enjoy your week.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Gigi, I hope you have a good week, too!
Delete