The Turtle of Oman, a novel - Naomi Shihab Nye, illustrated
by Betsy Peterschmidt
I
can see why others might speak of this story as a little slow. There is a build
up to the end, but really no exciting crisis requiring action, except in the
hearts of the boy, Aref and his grandfather, Sidi. Aref lives in Muscat, Oman,
on the edge of the Arabian Peninsula and is moving to Michigan in the United
States with his parents who will be spending the next three years studying for
their doctorates. And Aref, about ten, has to leave his home, his room, his
cat, Mish-Mish (meaning ‘apricot’), his school, his city. He doesn’t want to.
The biggest thing of course that he will miss is his grandfather.
The
book shows the days before departure as Aref and Sidi spend time together on
little adventures, like driving out into the desert to the Night of a Thousand
Stars camp, and visiting the beach where sea turtles lay their eggs. Nye sets
the tone of learning with Aref explaining that the goal in their family is to
learn something new every day, and woven in between the other experiences, the
book shows handwritten notes of what was learned that day, like about turtles,
Martin Luther King, and possible birds to see on their camping trip. A second
thread holding the story is that within each time together, Sidi finds one
special rock, explaining why it will help him remember that time. The culture is woven into the story also as
Aref says his goodbyes to the traditions in his city, like the calls to prayer.
It’s
a nostalgic time of goodbye, with Aref resisting filling his “one” suitcase no
matter how many times his mother asks, and with Sidi breaking down only once,
on their final night together. The book might be challenging for young children
to enjoy if they are looking for great adventure. Yet for some who have moved
and had to say goodbye to a beloved home, this might be a good one. And it will
also please adults who’ve had to say goodbye to a beloved grandchild who moved
away, as I have. Naomi Nye’s writing is
pure poetry, no surprise. There is a wonderful passage about home that I will
share a little part: “What makes a home, a home?” and “Or maybe it was how the
beach air smelled--salty and sweet in whirls. You didn’t have to do anything to
feel comfortable here. You just walked inside, took a long breath and thought--Yes. Sure. Here I am.”
Little Tree - written and illustrated by Loren
Long
Loren Long’s simple illustrations as the seasons move from summer to
fall to winter, and on to spring, and Little Tree hangs on to his leaves. One
can imagine some child hanging on to childhood, from young to older. I’d love
to have read this to my middle school aged students, wondering if some would
admit they would still love to hang on to their toys just a bit longer. Or for
the younger children, imagining a tree not understanding that trees might just want to keep those leaves,
connecting to the feelings of some kind of loss. It’s a simple and beautiful
story.
I loved reading all the details of how engineer and inventor George
Ferris persuaded the 1893 World’s Fair Committee that he could build this
amazing thing that no one had ever built. And he would make it the tallest, and
he would make it safe. Just imagine, for
those who had not climbed a mountain, there was no way to get a view from very
high except from a building. At that time there weren’t many what we now call
skyscrapers. Many, many people and parts were gathered to get this
accomplished. Great story, told well in the text and in the gorgeous
illustrations filled with views of the fair, the look of the buildings and the
people, and of course, many pictures of the wheel.
Swan: The Life and Dance of Anna Pavlova - written by Laurel Snyder and
illustrated by Julie Morstad
This picture book seems nearly like the dancer herself, a fairy tale
look for a fairy tale. Anna Pavlova grew up poor, the daughter of a laundress,
but one day her mother took her to see a ballet performance, and she was
transformed. Finally, after waiting two years, she was admitted to the ballet
company. Skinny and underdeveloped, she
still thrived and became what many think is the greatest dancer of all time.
Her story is told by Snyder as if she was really there, living Anna’s life. And
Morstad’s illustrations fill the pages with the magic of ballet and of Pavlova.
At the ballet: “Her feet wake up! Her skin prickles. There is a song, suddenly,
inside her.” It’s both a story of a gifted person in history that many of us
seem to know, and one of sadness because she died so young.
A Bird Is A Bird - written and illustrated by Lizzy
Rockwell
I love this book, just right for young children who don’t know very much
about birds. Piece by piece, Lizzy Rockwell tells the tale of the puzzle that
is a bird. What makes it, and how that works. Beautiful pictures of so many
birds, and a few animals who aren’t, help explain the necessary parts.
Next: I have Ruth Sepetys’ Salt To
The Sea from Net Galley, excited to begin!
Special News! Three people mentioned they
would like to win the farm Christmas book giveaway that I shared last Monday.
Here is the basket with the names (old-fashioned way), and here is the winner.
If you will contact me with your address, I’ll send it on to the publisher. Congratulations, Jane Heitman Healy!
I also love A Bird is a Bird Thinking it would be a wonderful mentor text - going to try it as inspiration with my class in the spring.
ReplyDeleteIt really is a wonderful book. Glad to hear you like it, too, Carrie.
DeleteI liked the turtles fact in each chapter. Yeah, it was a bit slow for me.
ReplyDeleteI know that it would be slow for some, Earl. Each book isn't for everyone.
DeleteThe writing is so gorgeous in Swan. I loved it. Turtle has been on my TBR for over a year now. Really ought to get to that! Slow starts are challenging for me these days. I feel like I don't have the attention span and focus I used to have or that I usually have for reading.
ReplyDeleteI did love Swan, don't know why I took so long to read it, but there are many this year that I've so loved. Turtle of Oman definitely isn't for everyone. Sometimes I struggle with some too.
DeleteYours is the second I've read about Swan today. It sounds breathtaking. I also want to read Little Tree (my daughter is hanging onto to me reading her bedtime stories as she looks toward college next year. It sounds like the perfect book for her now) and Turtles.
ReplyDeleteLittle Tree does sound perfect for you and your daughter, Kay. It's a very sweet book.
DeleteI read the Turtle of Oman. Yes, slow. I prefer Naomi Nye's poetry to her prose. There were moments of beauty, but I don't think I could sell it to my students who want action.
ReplyDeleteI missed out on getting Swan at NCTE, but it's on my list. Hearing Laurel Snyder talk about her passion made me want to read it.
I think the Ferris Wheel won an NCTE award.
Thanks, Margaret. Hope you will get a chance to read and "see' Swan, too.
DeleteYes, I definitely agree about The Turtle of Oman being slow. I was also a tad disappointed that the story never actually took place in Ann Arbor since that is essentially where I'm from and I would have loved to read about Aref acclimating to life in Michigan. But what I DID love about the book was that it showed a young character with a quiet, peaceful existence in the Middle East. Definitely a counter-narrative to what we're used to hearing.
ReplyDeleteYes, it was a nice look at a middle east family. I wonder if she thought about a sequel, Aref in Michigan?
DeleteThere's something to be said for quiet, simple books - action-packed or gentle, slow or fast-paced, readers of all ages can need different books at different times in their lives, and I'm glad we have such variety to offer young readers today - there really is something for everyone!
ReplyDeleteAgreed, Jane. I know a few students in the past who may have liked this book, and the times between grandson and grandfather. Thanks for your perspective, too.
DeleteMy class received Swan in a package of new picture books sent to us by Sophie Blackall. It is a gorgeous book and very popular with several of the girls in my class. The illustrations along with the text are simply wonderful.
ReplyDeleteHow wonderful for you and your class. So nice of Sophie Blackall. It is a lovely book! Thanks, Jana.
DeleteLaurel Snyder gave such a wonderful presentation at NCTE that Swan is now on my radar, a book that may not have been otherwise. Glad you enjoyed it!
ReplyDeleteI've heard others tell about her presentation. Wish I could have heard it. Hope you'll find Swan soon!
DeleteI loved, loved Little Tree. I agree that the book is simple but quite beautiful. I had a difficult time reviewing it because I couldn't quite capture the magic of the book. I wanted to write, "Just read it!" I hope you have a great week!
ReplyDeleteYes, it is one to own, I think, Ricki. Thank you. I hope your week is good, too. I've started the Sepetys book and it is wonderful.
DeleteThe Turtles of Oman reminded us of Journey by Patricia Maclachlan - Such an important book! We can't wait to read Swan - Everyone keeps writing about it and we haven't gotten our hands on it yet. Hopefully, it will come in from the library over vacation.
ReplyDeleteYes! I had forgotten about Journey. Thanks for reminding me, maybe time to re-read? Enjoy Swan!
DeleteI just read Swan yesterday and fell in love with it. I've been looking forward to reading Nye's Turtle of Oman - I think her lyrical and slow-paced writing would benefit from a more dynamic book cover, but that's just me.
ReplyDeleteI've had The Turtle of Oman for a while, & so don't remember why I bought it. There must have been a good review, or I bought it because it was by Naomi Nye. As you see, I liked it, but really am not sure what student I might recommend it too. Yes, Swan is beautiful, must be a special gift for young dancers! Thanks, Myra.
Delete